full circle
Full Circle > Getting Started >

Model Lessons

Adding a drop of information fluency to 20th Century lessons

Hypothesis: Transforming non-digital lesson plans into digital experiences requires little effort

To test this we pulled half a dozen lessons from the Internet that were not digital. That is, other than being posted on the Internet, the original lessons did not involve students in searching for digital collections.

Our goal in transforming these lessons was to integrate at least one digital information fluency comency into an existing lesson in such a way as not to alter the original objective of the lesson. Could we accomplish two different goals in the space of one? What this experiment taught us.

Transformed Lessons, by subject and grade level:

Language Arts: PARTS OF SPEECH (grade 3)

Language Arts: WRITE A TRAINING MANUAL (4-8 grades)

Science: MANY USES OF PLANTS (grades 6-8)

Science: SOMETHING FISHY (grades 5-12)

Social Studies: FRIENDS OF THE DESERT (grades 7-8)

Social Studies: ENTREPRENEURS/CAREERS (high school)

Model Lesson 1 -- Language Arts: PARTS OF SPEECH (grade 3)

There is a natural connection between parts of speech and effective keywords in queries. Certain parts of speech are more effective as search terms. For example, proper nouns are better than verbs; pronouns and prepositions are often ignored by search engines.

Goal: Integrate information fluency and an exploration of parts of speech as an extension of the original lesson.

Outline of Changes
Original Lesson: Parts of Speech Review Integrated Lesson
GRADE LEVEL 3  
OBJECTIVE(s): Students will be able to:
  • work within a group to develop the correct answer
  • describe how to diagram a sentence by first arranging classmates into a human diagram
  • understand the concepts of modifiers
  • understand the concepts of helping verbs
  • diagram a sentence correctly at their seats
Our transformation adds these objectives:
  • Identify key concepts in a research question
  • Create effective and efficient search queries by translating a natural language question into a search query (selecting initial keywords)
ACTIVITIES AND PROCEDURES:
  1. Review Parts of Speech with students: Noun, Verb Adjective
  2. Write the following sentence on the board: My furry dog BooBoo barked when a big truck drove by our house
  3. Together with students, identify the parts of speech in the sentence. Circle then nouns in blue (dog, BooBoo, truck, house), the verbs in red (barked, drove), and the adjectives in green (furry, big)
  4. Distribute copies of the Parts-of-Speech Field Trip Student Printable (PDF) to students. Read the directions aloud and allow time for students to complete the worksheet.


  5. Extension activities omitted
In Place of the PDF activity (#4):

If you wanted to find online information about booking a field trip to a farm, what words would you need? Introduce the concept of Keyword Challenges to reinforce the idea of meaning: what is this sentence really talking about?

  1. What is our question? (Have students suggest what they would enter into a search engine if they wanted to take a field trip to a farm)
  2. On separate cards, write out each word of the search phrase or sentence (give each card to a different student)
  3. What are the most important words? (these students step forward)
  4. What words wouldn't you need? (these students sit down)

This creates an opportunity to talk about the importance of numbers and nouns, especially proper nouns, the lesser importance of adjectives--unless they identify an aspect that makes the noun unique, and the relative unimportance of verbs and adverbs for finding information (what they do is less important than what they are—why? There are often many things they can do or that can be done to them and many ways to express this).

Common parts of speech (articles, prepositions, etc.) are unimportant.

How many words are left? Can you think of other words that could be substituted which might improve the meaning?

Model Lesson 2 -- Language Arts: WRITE A TRAINING MANUAL (4-8 grades)

In the original lesson, students may search for information on training s using print sources, interviews or the Internet. One Internet source is provided. If a visit to a veterinarian, shop or dog obedience school is not feasible, consider using the Internet to bring sources to the classroom.

The adaptation mainly prepares students for research, starting with the natural language of the assignment and translating it into effective queries. If students need a quick introduction to crafting effective queries, use several Keyword Challenges.

A second great application is to ask these questions: "Who would know the answer to this question?" "If we can't get to that person face-to-face, how can we find him or her on line?" This raises the issue of what digital collections are best to query.

Finally, and especially with older students, have them answer the question: "How can we tell if this information is written by an expert?" If an author's background cannot be determined, it's better not to use the information.

Outline of Changes
Original Lesson: Training Manual Integrated Lesson
GRADE LEVELS: 5 - 12  

Objective:Students will learn how to train a and create a training guide that anyone can use.

Our transformation adds these objectives:

  1. Identify key concepts in a research question
  2. Create effective and efficient search queries by translating a natural language question into a search query (selecting initial keywords)
  3. Select digital collections effectively and efficiently based on their characteristics
  4. Evaluate the quality of a search result to determine the reliability of its source (author)
ACTIVITIES AND PROCEDURES: Have children work in small groups to find information about animal training. Here are some suggestions to help children locate information:
  1. Get books or magazines about animal training from the library.
  2. Visit a veterinarian or a store owner. They may have free brochures that children can take home with them.
  3. Call or go to a dog obedience school and interview a trainer if there is a school near where you live.
  4. Help your students search the Internet for training information (one site is listed).
  5. Help children organize the information they gathered from the different sources into sections or chapters for the training guide. Then have children write a draft of the guide information.
  6. Have children exchange their drafts with one another to find out if their guides make sense and to proofread them. Then have them make a final copy, making any necessary changes. Suggest that they begin each chapter on a new page.
  7. Encourage children to draw pictures to go with the information.
  8. Put it all together. Guide children in inserting pictures in the appropriate places and fastening all the pages together.
  9. Make copies of the books for children to take home and share with their families. If a child has a trainable , such as a dog, encourage them to try to teach the a simple command.

Prepare the Natural Language task: Turn the assignment into a query.

  1. Keyword Challenges may be introduced to help students think about building effective search terms prior to searching.

  2. QuickPick: Searching for Answers may be used to help students think about alternate words that may be associated with information that satisfies their search.

  3. Decide where to look for the information: Have students think about where an expert animal trainer might post information. Consider searching for obedience schools rather than visiting one or writing emails to an expert rather than incurring the expense of an in-person visit.

    Conduct searches, collecting information for the project. Is the information written by an author who may be considered an expert? How do you know?

Model Lesson 3 -- Science: MANY USES OF PLANTS (grades 6 - 8)

The original lesson involves online research. Depending on students' familiarity with keywords and queries, playing a few Keyword challenges will sharpen their use of words as they look for scientific names, common names, locations where the plant or tree is grown, and so on.

This adaptation serves as a tutorial to help students use words more carefully as they search.

Outline of Changes

Original Lesson: Many uses of Plants Integrated Lesson
GRADE LEVELS: 6 - 8  

Objective: Students will broaden their knowledge of non-food plant products that are in common use.

Our transformation adds these objectives:

  • Create effective and efficient search queries by translating a natural language question into a search query (selecting initial keywords)

Internet Resource

PFAF Database Search
This comprehensive website contains data on more than 7,000 plants. Included are Latin and common names, plant uses, and geographic areas of growth. The site also has an advanced search function.

 
ACTIVITIES AND PROCEDURES:
  1. Ask students to make a list of objects that they think might be made from a plant or a tree. When students have finished, hold a class discussion on the items on their list. Suggest that students continue to add items to their list during the discussion.
  2. Ask students why it might be difficult to identify items made from plants (most items are not specifically labeled; many items are made to look like they're made from natural materials but are actually plastic or other man-made materials).
  3. Provide students with research materials. Then hand out one or more copies of the Plant Uses Research Form and World: Countries map to each student. From the list provided, assign one or two plants to each student. Depending on the number of students in your class, you may have more than one student study the same plant. Or you may wish to divide the class into small groups and assign one or more plants to each group.
  4. Explain to students that they will do research, focusing on five areas of information: scientific name, common name, location where the plant or tree is grown, one or more products that are made from this plant, and where the products are commonly used. Have students complete each section of the Plant Uses Research Form. Then have students mark on the world map the name of the country where the plant is grown.
  5. Have students share what they have learned with the class.

Prior to the research activity (#4), as a group, brainstorm queries that may be effective for finding one or more of the five areas of information, e.g., the “location where the plant is usually grown” (natural language wording taken from the worksheet).

  1. Keyword Challenges may be introduced to help students think about building effective search terms prior to searching.
  2. QuickPick: Searching for Answers may provide additional clues about words to include in the search

Model Lesson 4 -- Science: SOMETHING FISHY (grades K - 5)

As this lesson states, students identify parts of a fish and learn about the purpose of those parts.

The original lesson introduces younger students to basic fish anatomy. Prior to this lesson, students could be introduced to online searching. The transformation suggested here integrates brainstorming with going online to generate a list of keywords. The original lesson then continues as found on the web site:

Outline of Changes

Original Lesson: Something Fishy Integrated Lesson
GRADE LEVEL: 3  

Objective: Given the hypothetically evolved condition of the ocean, students will create a fish of the future, listing many, different, and unusual ways that their fish will adapt to survive.  The student will name the fish and create a labeled model of it.

Our transformation adds these objectives:
  • Create effective and efficient search queries by developing and applying vocabulary building strategies (read snippets to find better keywords)
  • Use a search engine effectively
ACTIVITIES AND PROCEDURES:
  1. After discussing different habitats, life cycles, and parts of animals, eggs, and fish, this group activity involves all students and all levels of ability.
  2. In advance, the teacher will have prepared a large picture of a fish and have the cards printed and laminated.
  3. Hang the picture on the blackboard and have the students come and sit on the floor.
  4. Ask for one student to pick a part and identify it. Next, have the student come to the picture and point to the part. Now have the student find the card with the correct word name and attach it to the large picture. (If the other students agree they smile, if they disagree, they frown. This helps to keep noise to a minimum.) Note: If the student is incorrect, guide them to the correct answer.
  5. Ask another student to come forward and pick the card that tells how that part helps the fish.
  6. Continue until all the parts and purposes have been identified. As the students return to their seats, the teacher will remove the names and purposes from the fish.
  7. Pass out the worksheet and have them put their name and date on the top.
  8. Allow the students time (about 10 minutes) to complete the worksheet and then check it with the group as the teacher puts the part names back on the large picture.
  9. Have the students take the worksheet home.
In place of creating cards with parts named, spend 5 to 10 minutes online looking for missing answers. Show a picture of a fish with parts circled but not named. What query would be effective to find a chart naming parts of a fish? At the end of the time, have students name the parts they found. Then continue with the original lesson.

 

Model Lesson 5 -- Social Studies: FRIENDS OF THE DESERT (grades 7 - 8)

This lesson includes a list of good questions for queries (e.g., How does land use lead to desertification? Would changing current land use help stop the spread of the desert?).

The altered lesson involves searching the Internet, first by guiding students to examine snippetss for clues to relevant information. Several snippets may be provided to demonstrate how snippets contain information clues and better keywords. The following example is based on the first question above (query = Africa land use desertification):

Land Resource Stresses and Desertification> in Africa | NRCS Soils

Vulnerability to desertification in Africa is assessed using the ... For detailed land use assessments, quantitative land quality assessments can be made.
soils.usda.gov/use/worldsoils/papers/desertification-africa.html - 79k

Desertification

By 1973, the drought that began in 1968 in the Sahel of West Africa and the land-use practices there had caused the deaths of more than 100,000 people and 12 ...
pubs.usgs.gov/gip/deserts/desertification/ - 13k

Relevant discoveries: land resource stresses, land use assessments, soils, drought, Sahel of West Africa, usda and usgs are sources of information. These look like good places to continue searching.

Outline of Changes

Original Lesson: Friends of the Desert Integrated Lesson
GRADE LEVELS: 7 - 8  
Objective: Students will hold a conference to learn how cooperation among nations might solve a problem that affects much of Africa.

Our transformation adds this objective:

  1. Create effective and efficient search queries by revising their search queries based on search results/feedback (selecting alternate keywords)

ACTIVITIES AND PROCEDURES:
  1. Have students study a climate map of the desert regions of Africa: the Sahara and Kalahari. Then have them use a political map to determine which African nations are in those regions. Point out that the maps make it clear that desertification, the process by which land becomes desert, is not limited to one country. Encourage students to discuss how cooperation among the countries they've listed might help fight desertification.
  2. Announce (and schedule) an upcoming Pan-African Conference on Desert Control and Reclamation. Divide the class into delegations, appointing two or more delegates to the conference from each of the nations in the desert region. Before the conference opens, each delegation is responsible for learning as much as it can about how the desert is affecting its nation.
  3. Appoint a conference chairperson or fill the role yourself. When the delegations come together as a conference, divide the group into committees to study the List of Topics and Questions provided or a list of your own. Explain that each committee, which should have members from several nations, is to produce a report that suggests answers to the questions posed. The reports should include ideas on positive steps African countries can take in cooperation with one another.
  4. Make the climax of the conference the presentation of the reports.

Integral to the lesson plan (#2), encourage the use of the Internet for research pertaining to "how the desert is affecting (the team's) nation."

Prior to going online, introduce the importance of reading snips carefully for valuable clues and relevant information.

Provide 2 - 3 snippets as an example of finding relevant information and better keywords for searching (such as the example shown above).

Questions:

1. Are these snippets relevant to our search? (yes)

2. What better keywords do we find here that may improve our search? (land resource stresses, land use assessments, soils, drought, Sahel of West Africa, usda and usgs)

Model Lesson 6 -- Social Studies: ENTREPRENEURS/CAREERS (high school)

The original lesson involves students in brainstorming ideas for a new business. With the help of a subject directory, students can quickly generate a diverse list of possible businesses. Some minimal instruction on how a subject directory is organized may be necessary. But once students start to browse--something they are naturally good at--they will encounter a rich array of topics that could be the basis for a future business.

The adapted lesson could be extended as a search challenge: can students find the final three business ideas using only the search directory? This demonstrates how much more efficient it is to use a search engine once a topic is defined. Finding a matching site by browsing in a subject directory is surprisingly difficult--mainly because of the 1 in 5 rule: the odds of matching a word used by another person (in this case the subject directory editor) is only 1 in 5.

Outline of Changes

Original Lesson: Entrepreneurs/Careers Integrated Lesson
GRADE LEVELS: 5 - 12  
Objective: Students will plan a new business and present it to a panel of local entrepreneurs. Our transformation adds this objective:
  1. Use a subject directory effectively.
Tasks:
  1. Have students offer ideas on how they would go about starting a new business. Suggest that one step might be consulting people who have successfully set up new businesses.
  2. Tell students they are going to work in teams to develop ideas for a new business and present it to a panel of business people. Develop, with student input, a list of local people who have started their own businesses. Appoint a committee of letter writers to develop a form letter inviting at least three such people to participate in the panel.
  3. Have each team brainstorm ideas for a new business. To help them develop their ideas, they can use the Business Plan Form, which is based on the five W's and an H.
  4. Have each team present its idea. Let the class vote to narrow down the final number to three. You might present these plans in advance to the panelists. Or choose a spokesperson from each group to make the presentation to the panel.
  5. In preparing for the panel, have students draw up general questions about entrepreneurship. These might include asking panelists how they started their businesses, where they got the ideas, what difficulties they encountered, and what general advice they would offer new business people.
  6. Have a recorder or recorders take notes on the ensuing discussion. Later, students can use these notes to summarize what they learned about setting up and developing a new business.
Task: As an option to brainstorming, have students browse a Subject Directory to look for ideas for a new business.
  1. Find 3-4 options and have everyone share. Then select one business idea for the project.
  Extension:

Challenge students to find one of the selected sites using only the subject directory (illustrates an ineffective use of subject directory for targeted search). Option: assign half the group to a subject directory, the other half to a search engine. Who can find relevant information first?

What this experiment taught us

We started with the hypothesis that transforming non-digital lesson plans into digital experiences requires little effort.

This experiment confirmed to us that it is easy to infuse non-digital lesson plans with digital searching skills. In fact, it took at least twice as long to format this article than it did to transform all six original lessons.

The transformations took a variety of forms: some as introductions to online research, others as substitutes for group brainstorming, others as lesson extensions. In all cases, a natural fit became apparent as we read the original lesson.

We've incorporated the process used to transform exisiting lessons in this QuickPick article.

The examples represented here demonstrate how simply 20th Century non-digital lessons can be transformed into opportunities that foster 21st Century information fluency.

Back to Previous Page